Israel discovery
reveals potential gas rich play March
2009
Eastern Mediterranean Tamar discovery reveals potential gas
rich play in Levantine basin
Regional analogies
also offer prospects for deeper oil
Jeremy Beckman Editor,
Europe Offshore March 2009 • wwwoftshore-maq.com
Further gas finds would help ease Israel’s energy
concerns.
The country’s sole production comes from the Man-B field in
shallow water off
the southern coast. The Gaza Marine discovery has yet to be put into
production.
Otherwise, the only external source of gas is a pipeline from
Egypt, but
throughput has been subject to interruptions
Test results from a gas discovery in
the Levantine basin point to an emerging subsalt play. The deepwater
well on the Tamar structure,
90 km (56 mi) offshore Haifa, Israel, encountered three productive
reservoirs
with thick sands in the Lower Miocene and net pay of more than 460 ft
(140m).
Gas flowed at a constrained rate of 30
MMcf/d over a limited
section of the lowest reservoir, and operator Noble Energy
believes a
production rate of over 150 MMcf/d could be feasible. It claimed the
find could
be the largest in its history, with a resource potential of around 5
tcf. The
water depth of 5,500 ft (1,680 m) was also the deepest by far for
any well to
date in Israeli waters.
Noble and its partners are set to
retain the rig, the Atwood Hunter, for two more
wells. The
first would be on Dalit, another Tertiary/Lower Miocene subsalt
prospect in
4,500 ft (1,372 m) of water in the Michal permit, 28 mi (45 km)
offshore,
which is already covered by 3D seismic. The second well would be a
step-out on
Tamar, in the Matan license.
Further gas finds would help ease
Israel’s energy concerns.
The country’s sole production comes from the Man-B field in
shallow water off
the southern coast. The Gaza Marine discovery has yet to be put into
production.
Otherwise, the only external source of gas is a pipeline from
Egypt, but
throughput has been subject to interruptions.
In recent years, Houston-based
Noble and local company
Delek Drilling have been the mainstays of Israeli E&P Prior to
Tamar, there
had been no exploration drilling for several years, but more
recently other
companies have picked up offshore concessions. These include Israeli
junior
PetroMed, which last year converted two deepwater exploration permits
in the Levantine
basin to drilling licenses (Sara and Myra) both a short distance from
the Matan
license. The company also operates an adjoining exploration permit
(Benjamin).
PetroMed’s interpretive studies of
existing geological and
seismic data since 2005 indicated strong potential for thermogenic gas,
and for
condensate and oil at deeper levels. The company’s acreage is close to
the
Tamar discovery and on trend with the Dalit structure. PetroMed also
has found
strong indications of deeper lying, light Jurassic oil, based on wells
closer
to the Israeli coast and via geological analogies with recent ultra
deep
discoveries in the Nile Delta to the south.
Hibernia ‘look-a-like’
The company describes its mission as “to discover, drill,
develop, and deliver oil and gas to Israel,” with a focus on
offshore targets.
It was formed in 1999, originally as a Nevada-based corporation,
by financial
and management consultant Hagai Amir. Four years later in Calgary, he
and
Russell Koch were introduced to the late Donald Axford, a Canadian
geologist
credited with finding the Hibernia field off Newfoundland. Axford believed he had “seen” another
Hibernia on seismic offshore Israel.
AJ Amir is chairman and CEO of
PetroMed, supported by
finance director Koch, who is based in Seattle. Other board
members include
Arlon Tussing, a former chief energy adviser to the US Senate and
now energy
consultant for the World Bank and Deutsche Bank.
The company’s exploration team of
experienced geologists and
geophysicists, all based in the UK, are headed by exploration
manager David
Peace. The team is complemented by external consultants RPS,
providing assistance
with 3D survey design and specialized data reprocessing, and
Aberdeen-based
contractors to help with early well planning.
For much of his exploration career
Peace has worked in the
greater Mediterranean region. He worked in Milan for Agip and Penn
Geophysical, and headed an interpretation team of eight geologists and
geophysicists for Agip reviewing much of the Italian offshore
region and the
Po Valley. In the 1990s, he was Texaco’s exploration manager,
based in Rome,
and a director of Texaco Italiana Spa.
After leaving Texaco in 1998, Peace was
an independent
exploration consultant and conducted a regional evaluation of the
entire
Eastern Mediterranean based on Spectrum’s regional seismic grid of
25,000-line
km (15,534 mi).
“Spectrum had a regional seismic grid
around Cyprus and
Lebanon,” he explains, “based on a reprocessed speculative survey
originally
acquired in 1975. This data was a wide-spaced regional survey from
southern
Turkey to the eastern Nile Delta, and covered the thrust zone
between Anatolia
and North Africa — one of the major continental margins — and it
revealed a
very attractive new play.
“The old data had imaged the entire
Levantine basin, which
had not really been explored by any of the countries in the
region. Due to
recording limitations, they had only recorded the first five to six
seconds of
data — hence also seeing only the top of the basin. However, when
Spectrum
acquired its 20,000 km (12,427 mi) of new seismic in 2001-2002, it
recorded
down to 12 seconds, which allowed us to see the deeper part of the
basin.”
The only prior wells in the area were
off southern Turkey
and had led to some small discoveries in the Iskendrun basin.
Spectrum’s new
seismic provided a more detailed 2D grid over offshore southern
Turkey,
Syria, Lebanon, Cyprus, Israel, Gaza, and the outer fringes of Egypt,
and was
designed to promote licensing rounds in these countries.
In 2001, when the surveys were being
acquired, the Lebanese
government was in talks about a first offshore round, but this never
came about
at the time. Cyprus also considered staging a round, although this did
not take
place until 2007-08.
“To date,” Peace adds, “there has been
no offshore drilling
either in Syria or Cyprus, and only one well offshore Lebanon.
Onshore Cyprus,
which is the epicenter of the collision zone with Africa, is one of the
toughest to interpret geologically in the world, but we see the
sedimentary
plays on the fringes of the Levantine basin as very interesting.”
In late 2002, Peace began evaluating
Spectrum’s entire
database for the eastern Mediterranean region, concluding the
program in fall
2003. The results looked very promising: “In the Levantine basin,
including
the Latakia thrust zone in the north, we identified some very
interesting
structural patterns which showed a lot of individual seismic leads,
from small
closures to much larger simple structural traps.”
Southerly analogy
To the south in the Nile Delta, exploratory drilling began
in earnest in the late 1990s. “British Gas started finding gas in
channel sands
in the shallow Pliocene section above the deeper Messinian salt
layer that
covers much of the Mediterranean,” says Peace. “Later, they followed
similar
channel features up the eastern Mediterranean coast to make
further biogenic
gas finds off Gaza and southern Israel.
“At that time I was with Texaco and to
us, the whole area
looked rather gas-prone in the early days. Later on, however, the focus
of Nile
Delta exploration switched to drilling through the Messinian salt zone,
and
over the last few years companies have found not just biogenic gas of
shallow
origin, but also deeper thermogenic gas and, more recently, condensate
and oil
4.5 km (2.8 mi) down in the high-pressure/high-temperature zone. So the
message
is clear: biogenic gas in the shallow section, but thermogenic gas,
condensate
and free oil in the deeper pre-salt section, a situation we believe
exists in
the Levantine basin as well.
“From our evaluation of the Spectrum
regional data, we can
see that the Levantine basin has some characteristics and
geological
conditions similar to the Nile Delta (although not at all
identical) and which
extend into PetroMed’s licenses. Inshore from our blocks, two older
wells have
already tested 800 b/d of light ‘Jurassic’ oil from deeper lying
Jurassic
strata underlying our permits. These excellent oil shows are almost
certainly
the result of migration from the deeper parts of the basin to the
west, and
provide further evidence for an active thermogenic hydrocarbon system
in the
deeper part of the Levantine basin, in part mirroring what we see off
Egypt.”
<>Exploratory leads
Following initial contact and dialogue with the Geophysical
Institute of Israel near Tel Aviv, PetroMed submitted its initial
technical
presentations for its permit areas to the Ministry for National
Infrastructure
in Jerusalem early in 2006, and these were granted later that
year. Initial
evaluations continued to confirm the potential of the areas, and last
year the
company opted to convert the permits to three-year drilling
licenses.
The Sara and Myra licenses both cover
400 sq km (154 sq mi).
Peace and his team so far have identified two large prospective lead
areas, one
in each license, in water depths of around 1,100 m (3,609 ft). One is a
thick
four-way dip closure from Tertiary to Jurassic, which is on trend with
the
Dalit structure in the adjacent Noble-operated permit. The second
prospect is a
potential reef growth on top of an older high, which is in turn
overlain by potential
Cretaceous and Tertiary reservoirs, as confirmed in Tamar.
The company has a letter of agreement
for a 3D seismic
vessel, and alms to start acquiring 3D over the two license areas
by midyear,
followed by detailed processing and pre-stacked depth migration of the
data.
“We will do the interpretation
ourselves,” Peace says.
‘We’re happy that the structures are there from the 2D data, so the
main purpose
of the 3D seismic is to confirm internal geological detail within each
of the
structures to allow us to optimize future drilling locations.
‘We need 3D data primarily to define
these structures in
greater detail — we can see anomalies within them that cannot be
resolved by 2D
seismic. Thereafter, we plan to select our best drilling locations and
be ready
to spud our first well within two and a half years from now. At the
same time,
it is also a case of getting partners on board to share the well costs.”
According to Hagai Amir, PetroMed has
been in open dialogue
with several major oil companies in this regard. “At this time,” he
says, “we
are open to offers from potential new financial partners and strategic
partners
from the industry. Ideally, the partner we would prefer would be an
established
international oil and gas company with significant drilling
and operational
experience.
“PetroMed is currently operator of all
three licenses and
permits for all technical work up to the initial well spud, but we
would
welcome specialized geophysical technical assistance from suitably
experienced
new partners as well. As we are only a small company, we would
also prefer
that a more experienced oil company partner would operate as we
enter the
actual drilling phase.”
Water depths in the two drilling
permits extend to 1,500 m
(4,921 ft). Both carry initial three-year terms, but in the event
of a
discovery, these can be renewed for a further four years for
appraisal
drilling, and 25 years for subsequent development and production.
The work
obligations for the adjoining, 18-month exploration permit include
geological
studies and 2D seismic.
“Our long-term ambition,” says Amir,
“is to build a stronger
and stronger exploration position, work up opportunities that will
attract
further industry partners, and see them developed while retaining an
interest
therein. In time the company may also consider venturing outside Israel
to
explore other opportunities, but the recent discovery of Tamar has
confirmed
our belief in the region, and we are very happy with our current
acreage.”
Israel Noble Finds
Gas in
Deep waters Offshore Noble
Energy, Inc. 3/30/2009
Noble Energy has made a natural gas discovery at the Dalit prospect in
the
Michal license, offshore Israel. Located in approximately 4,500 feet of
water
and 30 miles offshore, the well was drilled by the Atwood Hunter
semi-submersible rig to a depth of 12,000 feet. Formation logs
identified more
than 110 feet of net pay in a high-quality reservoir.
Dalit represents the Company's second subsalt, lower-Miocene discovery
in the
under explored Levantine basin.
Charles D. Davidson, Noble Energy's Chairman, President and CEO, said,
"With the successes at Tamar and Dalit, we have potentially opened up a
substantial new resource basin, where we have an interest in about
three
million gross acres. We are moving forward with development plans to
bring
first production to Israel from this new region in 2012. At the same
time, we
continue to remain focused on the vast exploration potential remaining,
and we
plan to conduct new 3D seismic later this year over various leads in
our other
licenses in the area. Based on results from the seismic program, we
could see
further exploration in the region starting in the second half of 2010."
Production testing will be performed at Dalit after the well is
completed.
Subsequent to testing, the rig will return to the Tamar discovery in
the Matan
license to drill an appraisal well designed to better define the
resources of
Tamar.
Noble Energy operates both the Michal and Matan licenses with a 36
percent
working interest. Other interest owners are Isramco Negev 2 with 28.75
percent,
Delek Drilling with 15.625 percent, Avner Oil Exploration with 15.625
percent
and Dor Gas Exploration with the remaining four percent.
|
Israel Triassic
targets in exploration Pace speeds
Stephen Pierce Oil & Gas Journal July
5, 2004
Zion Oil & Gas, an exploration company with offices in
Dallas and
Israel, is exploring on its 95,800-acre Ma'anit-Joseph License in
north-central Israel.
Using all available resources including over 400 km of
seismic, well
completion data, and gravity-magnetic survey data, Zion is joining in
and aggressively pursuing the exploration for hydrocarbons in Israel.
Recent discoveries of Triassic oil in north-central Israel have spurred
oil companies in their exploration efforts.
Exploration history
Petroleum exploration began in Israel in 1947 on a surface
feature in
the Heletz area of central Israel.
Since then 470 wells have been drilled in the country, and
most have
penetrated depths ranging from 1,500 ft to over 21,000 ft. However,
many of the wells were drilled on shallow surface features.
The first discovery was the Heletz-1. The well was completed
in 1955
and produced oil from Lower Cretaceous Heletz sands (5-30 m thick). The
field is estimated to have had some 50 million bbl of 30º gravity
oil in place.(1)
Other onshore fields and discoveries include Ashdod, Kokhav,
Zuk
Tamrur, Gurim, Meged, and Emunah. Subcommercial and commercial onshore
gas fields include Zohar (65 bcf recoverable), Kidod, Kanaim, Sadot (35
bcf), Ashdod, Shiqma, and Notera.
Offshore exploration began
in the 1990s with the subsequent discoveries
of Noa (300 bcf), Or, Mari-B (1.2 tcf), Nir, and Gaza Marine (1.5 tcf)
fields.
Most recently, exploring in north-central Israel, in April
2004 Givot
Olam Oil Ltd., Jerusalem, converted its exploration license to a
production lease following oil discoveries in the Triassic Meged-4
well, immediately south of the Ma'anit-Joseph license (Fig. 1).
The objective at Ma'anit is the Triassic reefal dolomite,
the Mohilla
formation. Many Triassic oil and gas fields are located in the area
including Butmah, Sufaiya, and Alan fields in Iraq, Souedie, Rumailan,
Jebbissa, and Tishreen fields in Syria,(2) and Mila, Gela, and Ragusa
oil
fields in the central Mediterranean.
On a large structure in
north-central Israel, the Ma'anit-1 well was
spudded in 1995. The primary objective was Triassic carbonates.
However, after reaching a depth of 2,335 m (7,661 ft) with very minor
oil shows in the Jurassic section,3 the well was abandoned due to
insufficient funds.
Zion was then awarded the Ma'anit-Joseph license, completed
its 2001-02
work commitments and now is ready to begin its drilling program.
Tectonics and structure
Located today on the northwestern border of the
Arabian-Nubian shield
in midlatitudes,(4) Israel in Upper Triassic time was in an equatorial
position. Carbonate deposition occurred throughout the Proto
Mediterranean Sea and Arabian platform.
A large stratigraphic/structural feature was independently
confirmed by
gravity and magnetics and seismic surveys in north-central Israel
within Zion's license area.
Located on the regional
north-south trending structural Gerar high
(Fig. 2), Triassic reefs and
reefal carbonate sediments formed along this Paleozoic high at Ma'anit
and were folded as the result of the Syrian arc compression of Late
Cretaceous age which created the commonly named Um al Fahm anticline.
These Triassic reefs trend generally east-west.
In the northern Ma'anit license area the largest reef, the
Ma'anit "A,"
has been mapped seismically to have an areal closure of some 8,000
acres
(Fig. 3).
The
smaller "B" and
"C" reefs combined are 6,000 acres. The Joseph reefs, located in the
southern part of the Ma'anit-Joseph License, offer further exploration
opportunities. Ma'anit-1 stratigraphy
The stratigraphy in the license area is comprised primarily
of
Cretaceous through Triassic carbonates, shales, evaporites, and
intermittent volcanics (Fig. 4).
Ma'anit-1 drilled 1,825 m (5,987 ft) of Upper to Lower
Cretaceous
carbonates with intermittent volcanics. Upper Jurassic
carbonates lie
directly below the Cretaceous sediments to a total depth of the well at
2,335 m (7,651 ft).
Well ties with seismic and
data from surrounding wells strongly suggest
that the top of the Triassic is at 3,850 m (12,631 ft) and the top of
the primary objective, the Mohilla reef, is at 4,000 m (13,123 ft). The
secondary objective, the Ra'af/Zafir, is expected to be at a depth of
4,600 m (15,092 ft).
Hydrocarbon sources
Four sources account for the hydrocarbons generated in
Israel.
The Jurassic Barnea
formation sources the coastal oil fields such as
Heletz.
In the Dead Sea area, rocks from the Late Cretaceous are believed the
source.
The sources for the oil found in Triassic reservoirs are
considered Triassic and
possibly Silurian age.
The recent oil discoveries immediately south of Zion's
license suggest
a Silurian source. Oil samples in the noncommercial Meged-2 well were
analyzed and a Silurian source was identified.
Potential Triassic source rocks are known throughout the
region. The
Upper Triassic source rocks found in the adjacent Northern Highland-1
well in Jordan contains source rocks with TOCs varying from 0.5% to
1.9%.3
In Israel proper, Triassic source rocks were identified in
the
Massada-1 (TOC 0.72%), Hazerim-1 (1%), Ramallah-1 (0.8%), Deborah-2A
(0.75%), and the Ga'ash-2 (1.65%) wells.(5 )
Reservoir
characteristics
The primary reservoir, the Mohilla formation, is Triassic in
age
(Carnian/ Norian) and is composed of dolomitized reefal carbonates.
The thickness of the Upper Triassic sediments varies from
914 m to
2,385 m. Porosity is estimated to be near 10%.(6)
Although no oil has been produced from Triassic formations
in Israel,
the equivalent Kurra Chine formation in Iraq has a similar average
porosity of 10% as observed in the Butmah-2 well.(2)
The secondary reservoir is the Zafir/ Ra'af formations of
Middle
Triassic age (Anisian/Ladinian). These formations consist of fractured
dolomites interbedded with black shales and some limestones.
Porosities range from 6% to 39% in the Ga'ash-2.(7)
Zion work plan
Zion at present plans to re-enter the Ma'anit-1 well.
The original well encountered minor oil shows from 1,860 m
(6,102 ft)
to a total depth of 2,335 m (7,661 ft) from Jurassic (Oxfordian to
Bathonian) carbonates. However, with encouraging hydrocarbon shows,
large structure, multiple Triassic objectives, and new field
discoveries directly south of the concession, Zion has a strong
probability of making a significant discovery of some 484 million bbl
of oil.
After completion of the
Ma'anit-1 well, Zion will then explore the
Ma'anit "B" and Joseph prospects in the southern part of the
concession. The larger areal extent of the Joseph reefs, 12,000 acres
in the permit area, provide additional upside potential.
References
1.Oil Fields Exploration, "Ma'anit-1 Well Completion
Report," Oil
Fields Exploration Ltd., 1995.
2.Sadooni, F., and Alsharhan, A., 2004, "Stratigraphy,
lithofacies
distribution, and petroleum potential of the Triassic strata of the
northern Arabian plate," AAPG Bull., Vol. 88, 2004.
3.Well completion log, Ma'anit-1, Oil Fields Exploration
Ltd., 1995.
4.Stoakes, F., "Triassic Reef Project Northern Israel
(Ma'anit),"
Stoakes Consulting Group, Calgary, Canada, 1991.
5.Cohen Z., "Hydrocarbon Potential of Israel," Oil
Exploration
(Investments) Ltd., 1988.
6.Harris, J., "Sample Study, No. 1 Asher/Atlit, Israel,"
John F. Harris
Consulting Geologist, unpublished report, 1983.
7."Ga'ash-2 Geological Completion Report," Oil Exploration
(Investments) Ltd., 1984. Bibliography
Ginzburg, A., and Eppelbaum, L., (undated), "A 3-D
reinterpretation of
the Ma'anit gravity anomaly," Tel Aviv University.
Zion Oil & Gas, "Prospect Presentation for the Joseph
Project in
Israel, Zion Oil & Gas report submitted to the Israel petroleum
commissioner and available to the public in Israel," 2003.
The author Stephen Pierce (pierce@ectisp.net)
is a consulting geologist with over
25 years' exploration experience worldwide. When working with Superior
Oil Co. and exploring in Israel in 1980, he wrote a basin analysis
study for the state of Israel at its request. He has a BS
degree in
geology from Long Beach State University and an MS degree in geology
from San Diego State University.
|